AdobeStock_188664020_bearb_web

 

The times when maintenance was considered a necessary evil are definitely over - certainly not only in the wind energy industry.

The wind industry is decisively different from conventional energy conversion. With the purchase of a wind turbine (WTG), an investor can really only positively influence results by optimizing operating costs, and the maintenance and servicing costs contained therein. Experience shows that the operating costs for wind turbines can be significantly higher than expected, contrary to the assumptions published by BWE in the early 2000s.

So how can maintenance and servicing be optimized? Ultimately, answers must be found to the following, interrelated questions:

  1. How do you make the importance of maintenance clear to investors?
  2. What are the current and future challenges and risks?
  3. What are the necessary resources (personnel, spare parts, etc.) and how accessible are they?
  4. What is the role of AI in standardization and digitization?
  5. What are the risks and opportunities associated with the technological developments of wind turbines?

 The answers to these questions can help to find and structure the way to an optimized maintenance process.

 

Holger Fritsch is the CEO of Bachmann Monitoring GmbH in Rudolstadt.

_DSF3695_bearb

The first question "Investors and their relationship to maintenance", relates to CAPEX and OPEX, as indirectly suggested in the previous section.

The acquisition of information is an essential part of any modern maintenance concept. This means that every multi-megawatt wind turbine must have systems that monitor and record conditions.

These include systems, known for many years, such as condition monitoring systems to monitor the condition of the drivetrain.

In the future, however, due to ever larger and more complex structures - especially rotor blades, (hybrid) towers (with concrete and steel structures) and foundations - systems will be required for holistic continuous condition monitoring: Structural Health Monitoring systems (SHM systems). As confirmed by modern examples, when building structures are affected by massive damage, there is danger to life and limb as well as to the investment. The measured values from SHM systems can be used to avoid unfavorable operating conditions and thus significantly reduce the dynamic loads acting on structures.

It makes sense here to take a holistic approach, so that every monitoring task does not require a different procedure, or at least to work with uniform interfaces that connect systems efficiently. This reduces the effort, which should not be underestimated, of managing many different measuring systems in order to generate the expected benefits from the information contained in these systems.

 "Challenges and risks"

In essence, this comes down to an analysis of the services provided by an organization (e.g., the combination of operations management and service) and their maintenance processes. Challenges include, for example, distributed locations, type diversity and lack of personnel, as well as the strategic orientation of the organization. Hidden risks may lurk in contracts with OEMs.

 

iStock-117702332_lichtpunkt_bearb

Scarce resources in spare parts, personnel and service providers

This issue is closely related to the organization’s size and its ability to realize economies of scale. Many WTGs of a certain type may justify the stockpiling critical components. Conversely, the greater the diversity of turbine types and greater the distance between wind farms, the more information should be provided by turbines (via SCADA or measurement systems) to plan targeted service interventions.

The current market situation will bring about significant change. Supply chains are being restructured and spare parts are significantly more difficult to obtain. Existing crane capacities will be used primarily for new construction, and necessary repairs may not receive the same priority. This also applies to transmission repairs, which logistically cannot be accommodated in a fully utilized series production.

 Demographic developments are already impacting the labor market when it comes to personnel requirements. In future, it will certainly become even more difficult to find motivated personnel who also meet the necessary physical requirements over the long term. In addition, a decentralized energy industry requires more personnel on an ad hoc basis than a centralized energy supply. This leads immediately to the next question:

What does AI/AI have to do with standardization and digitization?

 Demographic changes are driving the need for digitization and the associated opportunities for the profitable use of new technologies. In the future, AI will play a major role in reducing personnel requirements while still being able to efficiently manage a larger portfolio. However, AI is not a magic formula; it requires framework conditions. Even if you wanted to implement digitization without standardization, you would quickly encounter almost insurmountable hurdles. This starts with adequate file naming and the definition of uniform storage locations. The application of AI is much more successful when structured processes are in place.

 

AdobeStock_277626077_314267763_lichtpunkt_bearb

Risk and opportunities of WTG technological developments

Ongoing increases in plant performance are forcing the use of new technologies and the use of new production processes. For gearbox systems, this means focusing on the use of plain bearings. Plain bearings offer considerable cost advantages in terms of lower material consumption, but also in terms of size. However, for these bearing arrangements to function properly, operating conditions must first be mastered. These can no longer be adequately represented by the simple sequence control systems provided by the respective OEMs.

At the same time, transmission suppliers can now become system suppliers and supply software modules that - depending on the network and market situation - allow the selection of controlled, generation-optimized or lifetime-optimized driving curves.

The increasing use of bus systems in plants, which enable the coupling of different components and simple commissioning, therefore starts to make sense. In addition, this significantly reduces cabling requirements.

The risk of this development, however, is precisely whether OEM component suppliers (from rotor blades to towers) have the strength to become system suppliers, and the question of how the OEMs will behave in the face of this paradigm shift. However, if this change fails, the result will be an abundance of weak points and even serial damage.

This brings us back to the headline, but it’s no longer about old wine in new bottles, it’s about survival of the fittest.